Michael J. Behe A (R)evolutionary Biologist
Topic

Kenneth R. Miller

statue-of-sir-charles-darwin-at-the-natural-history-museum-in-london-stockpack-adobe-stock
Statue of Sir Charles Darwin at The Natural History Museum in London
Image licensed via Adobe Stock

Kenneth R. Miller and the Problem of Evil, Part 3

(This is the third of three posts on Kenneth Miller and the problem of evil.) I think the reason for Miller’s deep disdain of a relatively minor difference in our positions on evolution is not scientific. Rather, it’s theological. It’s called the problem of evil. Briefly stated, if God is responsible for designing not only the lovely parts of biology, but also the dangerous and nasty parts as well, then we have a theological problem on our hands. What kind of a God designs not only pretty flowers, but deadly malaria, too? Is God actually malicious? On the other hand, if God simply designed a process like Darwinism that He knew would lead to life, then, the thinking goes, He Read More ›

earth-and-other-planets-with-atmosphere-in-deep-space-sci-fi-wallpaper-exploration-of-the-space-elements-of-this-image-furnished-by-nasa-stockpack-adobe-stock
Earth and other planets with atmosphere in deep space. Sci fi wallpaper. Exploration of the space. Elements of this image furnished by NASA
Image licensed via Adobe Stock

Kenneth R. Miller and the Problem of Evil, Part 2

(This is the second of three posts on Kenneth Miller and the problem of evil.) Let me emphasize the last point of my previous post: Miller and I are only quibbling over the extent of design in the universe. Thefact of design, the principle of design, we agree on. Now, let’s look a little closer at where Ken Miller draws the limits of design (the edge of evolution, one might say). Although they are clearly necessary, is there reason to suppose that the bare laws and constants of the universe — even if properly tuned — are sufficient to assure life occurs in our universe, as Miller supposes? The answer is no — many other features than just the bare laws of the universe have to be gotten Read More ›

astrology-astronomy-earth-outer-space-solar-system-mars-planet-milky-way-galaxy-elements-of-this-image-furnished-by-nasa-stockpack-adobe-stock
Astrology astronomy earth outer space solar system mars planet milky way galaxy. Elements of this image furnished by NASA.
Image licensed via Adobe Stock

Kenneth R. Miller and the Problem of Evil, Part 1

(This is the first of three posts on Kenneth Miller and the problem of evil.) Brown University biologist Kenneth R. Miller has penned a second review of The Edge of Evolution, this one for the Catholic magazine Commonweal (subscription required). In the new review Miller alludes to some scientific points from his first review inNature. (I refer readers to my previous rejoinder to that on this blog.) But much of the second review turns on the theological implications of the book. In the new review Miller seems truly astounded that I argue that common descent is very strongly supported: Those hoping that Behe would argue for a biblical version of human origins will be shocked. Indeed, Behe tells his readers that there must be “no Read More ›